Making magic easy for every occasion
Custom sugar cookies
Order NowHand crafted, just for you
Each cookie set is custom designed and made from scratch. From custom 3d printed cookie cutters to hand painted details, I give special attention to each cookie design.
Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or looking for a unique gift, Your custom sugar cookies are sure to create some magic.
COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES IN NJ
SUGAR COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES!
Perfect for a fun night out with friends or a unique team building activity, and learn something while you’re at it! You’ll walk away from our classes with 3-6 beautifully decorated cookies — done completely by you. Recipes, icing consistency, practice forms, pre-made cookies — everything you need is included along with live instruction.
Learn More
Behind The Scenes
@makingmagiceasy
🎉🌮 Theme Thursday: Baby's First Fiesta! 🌮🎉
Hey, moms! Ready to celebrate your little one’s big milestone? Check out this fun inspiration board for Baby’s First Fiesta! 🎈✨ From colorful decorations to cute outfits and tasty treats, I’ve gathered some great ideas to make the day extra special.
Want to dive into all the cute goodies? You can find everything you need in the link in my bio! Let’s make this fiesta one to remember! 🎊💖
What’s your favorite fiesta item? Share below!
#BabysFirstFiesta #ThemeThursday #PartyInspo #MakingMagicEasy
Paw-sitively perfect for a 3rd birthday! 🐾🎉
🐶💖 Local moms, let’s make your next celebration unforgettable with delicious treats that are almost too cute to eat!
DM to place your order!
#PawPatrolParty #CustomCookies #LocalMoms #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
Hey, friends! I’m on the hunt for ideas to stuff my girls' Easter baskets this year. I know I can’t just fill them with cookies (even though that would be super easy!), so I’d love to hear your suggestions for fun goodies for my 5 and 7-year-old daughters! 🎀💕
Help me out with your ideas in the comments! 🌼
And speaking of cookies… if you’re looking for something sweet to add to your own baskets, I’ve got adorable options available! Orders are open until April 13th (link in bio)! 🍪💖
Come on 🍀 “cl-over” and treat yourself to a class for green thumbs and sweet tooths! We have a few seats left for April 7, so sign up ASAP (link in bio)!
#MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #GirlsNightOut #CookieDecoratingClass #WeekdayActivity #MomsNightOut #BYO #BakingClass
🎶🍪 Watch me take this cookie from basic to Mahjong magic! 🍪🎶
Ever wondered how I decorate these cookie orders? Join me as I add all the little details to this one! 🀄✨
It’s a messy, colorful process, and I’m all about it! Want to wow your friends at the next gathering? Custom cookies are definitely the way to go!
#CookieDecorating #MahjongCookies #CustomFun #BakingJoy #MakingMagicEasy #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
🌟🍪 Sweet Customer Feedback! 🍪🌟
Sharing this recent review: "The ‘paint your own’ cookies were so creative and delicious! The kids loved them! And the customer service was amazing. We will definitely be ordering more again."
Paint Your Own cookies are a hit for parties or just a fun activity to keep the kids busy! 🎨🍪 They make great favors, too!
Thank you for supporting my small business! If you want to add some sweet fun to your next get-together, just reach out! 💖
#CustomerLove #PaintYourOwnCookies #LocalParents #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
🐣✨ Last Call for Egg Your Yard Orders! ✨🐣
There's just ONE WEEK left to sprinkle some Easter magic in your yard! 🌷🐰 Don’t miss out on the chance to surprise your little ones with a yard filled with candy-filled eggs!
🧺✨ Remember, if you and your direct neighbors sign up together, you’ll each get an extra 10 eggs as a thank you! Tag your neighbors to get them in on the fun—let’s make this Easter unforgettable!
📅 Place your orders now! DM for details, and let’s get hopping! 🐾💖
#EggYourYard #EasterMagic #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
Hippity hop, these Bunny Nose Cookie Pops are back!
🐰🍭 Due to popular demand, I’ve decided to make a few more of these!
Perfect for Easter treats or just a sweet surprise. 🐣💖
Get yours before they hop away—order link in bio!
#BunnyNoseCookies #LocalMoms #SweetTreats #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
🌼🍪 Join Me at the Baker Street Spring Flea! 🍪🌼
Hey, Maplewood friends! I’m excited to be a vendor at the @bakerstreetflea on May 3rd from 11 AM to 5 PM! I’ll have a tasty variety of cookie treats, including my brand new chocolate-covered Oreos!
Choose from 3 fun themes: Wicked, Taylor Swift, and Minecraft, all available in packs of 2. 🧙♀️🎤🎮
I’d love to hear your thoughts—what other themes would you like to see? Drop your ideas in the comments! Can’t wait to see you there! 🎉💖
#BakerStreetSpringFlea #BakerStreetFlea #ChocolateCoveredOreos #LocalVendor #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
Paw-sitively perfect for a 3rd birthday! 🐾🎉
🐶💖 Local moms, let’s make your next celebration unforgettable with delicious treats that are almost too cute to eat!
DM to place your order!
#PawPatrolParty #CustomCookies #LocalMoms #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
Hey, friends! I’m on the hunt for ideas to stuff my girls' Easter baskets this year. I know I can’t just fill them with cookies (even though that would be super easy!), so I’d love to hear your suggestions for fun goodies for my 5 and 7-year-old daughters! 🎀💕
Help me out with your ideas in the comments! 🌼
And speaking of cookies… if you’re looking for something sweet to add to your own baskets, I’ve got adorable options available! Orders are open until April 13th (link in bio)! 🍪💖
Come on 🍀 “cl-over” and treat yourself to a class for green thumbs and sweet tooths! We have a few seats left for April 7, so sign up ASAP (link in bio)!
#MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #GirlsNightOut #CookieDecoratingClass #WeekdayActivity #MomsNightOut #BYO #BakingClass
🎶🍪 Watch me take this cookie from basic to Mahjong magic! 🍪🎶
Ever wondered how I decorate these cookie orders? Join me as I add all the little details to this one! 🀄✨
It’s a messy, colorful process, and I’m all about it! Want to wow your friends at the next gathering? Custom cookies are definitely the way to go!
#CookieDecorating #MahjongCookies #CustomFun #BakingJoy #MakingMagicEasy #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
🌟🍪 Sweet Customer Feedback! 🍪🌟
Sharing this recent review: "The ‘paint your own’ cookies were so creative and delicious! The kids loved them! And the customer service was amazing. We will definitely be ordering more again."
Paint Your Own cookies are a hit for parties or just a fun activity to keep the kids busy! 🎨🍪 They make great favors, too!
Thank you for supporting my small business! If you want to add some sweet fun to your next get-together, just reach out! 💖
#CustomerLove #PaintYourOwnCookies #LocalParents #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
🐣✨ Last Call for Egg Your Yard Orders! ✨🐣
There's just ONE WEEK left to sprinkle some Easter magic in your yard! 🌷🐰 Don’t miss out on the chance to surprise your little ones with a yard filled with candy-filled eggs!
🧺✨ Remember, if you and your direct neighbors sign up together, you’ll each get an extra 10 eggs as a thank you! Tag your neighbors to get them in on the fun—let’s make this Easter unforgettable!
📅 Place your orders now! DM for details, and let’s get hopping! 🐾💖
#EggYourYard #EasterMagic #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ
Hippity hop, these Bunny Nose Cookie Pops are back!
🐰🍭 Due to popular demand, I’ve decided to make a few more of these!
Perfect for Easter treats or just a sweet surprise. 🐣💖
Get yours before they hop away—order link in bio!
#BunnyNoseCookies #LocalMoms #SweetTreats #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
🌼🍪 Join Me at the Baker Street Spring Flea! 🍪🌼
Hey, Maplewood friends! I’m excited to be a vendor at the @bakerstreetflea on May 3rd from 11 AM to 5 PM! I’ll have a tasty variety of cookie treats, including my brand new chocolate-covered Oreos!
Choose from 3 fun themes: Wicked, Taylor Swift, and Minecraft, all available in packs of 2. 🧙♀️🎤🎮
I’d love to hear your thoughts—what other themes would you like to see? Drop your ideas in the comments! Can’t wait to see you there! 🎉💖
#BakerStreetSpringFlea #BakerStreetFlea #ChocolateCoveredOreos #LocalVendor #SouthOrangeNJ #MaplewoodNJ