Making magic easy for every occasion
Custom sugar cookies
Order NowHand crafted, just for you
Each cookie set is custom designed and made from scratch. From custom 3d printed cookie cutters to hand painted details, I give special attention to each cookie design.
Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or looking for a unique gift, Your custom sugar cookies are sure to create some magic.
COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES IN NJ
SUGAR COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES!
Perfect for a fun night out with friends or a unique team building activity, and learn something while you’re at it! You’ll walk away from our classes with 3-6 beautifully decorated cookies — done completely by you. Recipes, icing consistency, practice forms, pre-made cookies — everything you need is included along with live instruction.
Learn More
Behind The Scenes
@makingmagiceasy
Wishing everyone a thoughtful and peaceful Memorial Day. ❤️ Today, we remember and honor those who made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom.
Hoping you're enjoying time with loved ones, perhaps with a sweet treat in hand.
#MemorialDay #RememberAndHonor #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #ThankYou #HolidayWeekend
Summer is practically here, and my cookie calendar is heating up faster than a forgotten s'more by the campfire! 🔥
✨May & June: FULLY BOOKED! Thanks for keeping me so busy, cookie lovers! You're the sweetest.
✨July & August: Spots are filling up fast for some weeks, but I still have availability for others! Don't miss out on those summer celebrations.
Want to secure your spot but don't have all the deets yet? My "Pencil Me In" form is your new BFF! ✍️ It lets you snag a spot for your event even if the theme, date or guest count isn't totally locked down.
Find the link in bio to "Pencil Me In" and let's get you on the schedule!
#CustomCookies #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #PartyPlanning #SummerCookies #BookAhead #CookieAvailability #LocalBusiness #SupportSmall
🎉✨ Celebrate in Style! ✨🎉
I had so much fun creating this special cookie set for a customer's best friend’s 50th birthday! Featuring the initial "K" in pink with just a touch of sparkle — because every milestone deserves a little extra dazzle! 💖🍪
Here’s to turning 50 and fabulous! 🥂
#CustomCookies #BirthdayCelebration #FabulousAt50 #SparkleAndShine #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
Confession time: Do you ever wish you could keep ALL the cookies for yourself? Asking for a friend… 😉
Introducing the “already bitten” chocolate chip cookie! 🍪 My foolproof way to ensure maximum cookie-for-one enjoyment. Who’s gonna mess with a cookie that’s already been started? Mwahahaha!
Have a sneaky snack strategy? Let me know below!
#CookieHacks #ChocolateChipCookies #CustomCookies #DecoratedCookies #CookieArt #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #FunnyCookies #BakingHumor #TreatYourself #ShopLocal
It’s Theme Thursday! 🎉🐻🍯 Dive into the Hundred Acre Wood with a super sweet Winnie the Pooh party theme!
From adorable decor to honey-themed treats and charming invitations, we’ve got all the inspiration you need for a magical celebration. 🎈✨
#ThemeThursday #WinnieThePoohParty #PartyInspo #HoneyLovers #ChildhoodFavorites #PartyDecor #SweetCelebration #CreativeIdeas #PartyPlanningFun
Recently finished these cookies with the Chinese Double Happiness symbol! 💕🍪 Thanks to my awesome customer for letting me be part of this celebration. ✨
#CustomCookies #DoubleHappiness #CookieArt #CelebrationCookies #SweetTreats #BakingFun
Thrilled to share these custom cookies I made for @alexateebovoicestudio's recital this past weekend! 🎶🍪
#CustomCookies #RecitalTreats #AlexaTeeboStudio #CookieArt #BakingJoy #CelebrateCreativity #SweetInspiration #LocalLove
Kicking off graduation season with a big congratulations to all the college grads out there 🎓💪
Let me know in the comments below, who are you celebrating in the class of 2025!?
#GraduationSeason #CongratsGrads #CelebrateSuccess #NewBeginnings
🌊🍪 Join us on June 14th at our Family Cookie Decorating Class at @craftclubstudio in South Orange!
Decorate three delicious 'Under the Sea' cookies and get a special bonus Father's Day paint-your-own cookie.
Perfect for kids 5+ and their grown-ups. Reserve your spot now!
#FamilyFun #SummerActivities #KidsActivities #CookieDecorating #SouthOrangeEvents
Summer is practically here, and my cookie calendar is heating up faster than a forgotten s'more by the campfire! 🔥
✨May & June: FULLY BOOKED! Thanks for keeping me so busy, cookie lovers! You're the sweetest.
✨July & August: Spots are filling up fast for some weeks, but I still have availability for others! Don't miss out on those summer celebrations.
Want to secure your spot but don't have all the deets yet? My "Pencil Me In" form is your new BFF! ✍️ It lets you snag a spot for your event even if the theme, date or guest count isn't totally locked down.
Find the link in bio to "Pencil Me In" and let's get you on the schedule!
#CustomCookies #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #PartyPlanning #SummerCookies #BookAhead #CookieAvailability #LocalBusiness #SupportSmall
🎉✨ Celebrate in Style! ✨🎉
I had so much fun creating this special cookie set for a customer's best friend’s 50th birthday! Featuring the initial "K" in pink with just a touch of sparkle — because every milestone deserves a little extra dazzle! 💖🍪
Here’s to turning 50 and fabulous! 🥂
#CustomCookies #BirthdayCelebration #FabulousAt50 #SparkleAndShine #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ
Confession time: Do you ever wish you could keep ALL the cookies for yourself? Asking for a friend… 😉
Introducing the “already bitten” chocolate chip cookie! 🍪 My foolproof way to ensure maximum cookie-for-one enjoyment. Who’s gonna mess with a cookie that’s already been started? Mwahahaha!
Have a sneaky snack strategy? Let me know below!
#CookieHacks #ChocolateChipCookies #CustomCookies #DecoratedCookies #CookieArt #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #FunnyCookies #BakingHumor #TreatYourself #ShopLocal
It’s Theme Thursday! 🎉🐻🍯 Dive into the Hundred Acre Wood with a super sweet Winnie the Pooh party theme!
From adorable decor to honey-themed treats and charming invitations, we’ve got all the inspiration you need for a magical celebration. 🎈✨
#ThemeThursday #WinnieThePoohParty #PartyInspo #HoneyLovers #ChildhoodFavorites #PartyDecor #SweetCelebration #CreativeIdeas #PartyPlanningFun
Recently finished these cookies with the Chinese Double Happiness symbol! 💕🍪 Thanks to my awesome customer for letting me be part of this celebration. ✨
#CustomCookies #DoubleHappiness #CookieArt #CelebrationCookies #SweetTreats #BakingFun
Thrilled to share these custom cookies I made for @alexateebovoicestudio's recital this past weekend! 🎶🍪
#CustomCookies #RecitalTreats #AlexaTeeboStudio #CookieArt #BakingJoy #CelebrateCreativity #SweetInspiration #LocalLove
Kicking off graduation season with a big congratulations to all the college grads out there 🎓💪
Let me know in the comments below, who are you celebrating in the class of 2025!?
#GraduationSeason #CongratsGrads #CelebrateSuccess #NewBeginnings
🌊🍪 Join us on June 14th at our Family Cookie Decorating Class at @craftclubstudio in South Orange!
Decorate three delicious 'Under the Sea' cookies and get a special bonus Father's Day paint-your-own cookie.
Perfect for kids 5+ and their grown-ups. Reserve your spot now!
#FamilyFun #SummerActivities #KidsActivities #CookieDecorating #SouthOrangeEvents