Making magic easy for every occasion
Custom sugar cookies
Order NowHand crafted, just for you
Each cookie set is custom designed and made from scratch. From custom 3d printed cookie cutters to hand painted details, I give special attention to each cookie design.
Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or looking for a unique gift, Your custom sugar cookies are sure to create some magic.
COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES IN NJ
SUGAR COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES!
Perfect for a fun night out with friends or a unique team building activity, and learn something while you’re at it! You’ll walk away from our classes with 3-6 beautifully decorated cookies — done completely by you. Recipes, icing consistency, practice forms, pre-made cookies — everything you need is included along with live instruction.
Learn More
Behind The Scenes
@makingmagiceasy
Buckle up! It's Theme Thursday, and today we're soaring high with some fantastic Airplane Party inspiration! ✈️🌍
If you've got a little aviator on your hands, imagine a celebration where every detail takes flight – from runway-inspired decor to cloud-fluffy treats (and yes, I can make some incredible airplane cookies!). Think little suitcases filled with favors, in-flight snacks, and "passport photo" photo booth. It's all about making their dreams of adventure come true, right in our local skies!
What's your favorite part about an airplane theme? 👇
#ThemeThursday #AirplaneParty #PartyInspiration #CustomCookies #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #LocalMoms #PartyIdeas #KidsParty
👋 Hey there, cookie crew! It's Victoria, the face behind Making Magic Easy. You might know me for turning your party dreams into delicious cookie realities, but have you ever wondered how this whole sweet adventure started? 🤩
Well, rewind to August 2021. My youngest was turning two, and after a long stretch of no big parties (thanks, COVID), my "Two Sweet" birthday vision was HUGE. Being the relentless DIYer I am, I looked at those perfectly decorated sugar cookies I wanted and thought, "I can totally do that myself!" 🤣 (That's my then 2-year-old, in my mom's lap, who couldn't wait to dig into her cookies in the photo!).
And just like that, a new obsession was born (swipe to see a pic of the OG cookies)! What started as a labor of love for my daughter's bash quickly grew, and I officially started offering custom cookies to our amazing community in November 2023.
It's been a wild, wonderful ride, fueled by a lot of learning and a little bit of magic (and maybe some late-night Bravo). ✨
Tell me, what's something you DIY'd that totally surprised you with how much you loved it? 👇
#MeetTheBaker #MakingMagicEasy #CookieJourney #DIYSpirit #SmallBusinessStory #FirstCookies #MaplewoodMoms #HomeBaker #SupportLocal
Ready to make the whole place shimmer?! ✨🧜♀️
My latest mermaid set is giving major “Bejeweled” vibes with that airbrushed sheen. Perfect for your next sparkly celebration!
#CustomCookies #MermaidParty #Bejeweled #LocalNJ #SweetTreats #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #SupportLocal
Mermaid magic for a sweet 5th birthday! 🧜♀️✨
It's always extra special when I get to create for a friend, and being a tiny part of this perfectly curated mermaid extravaganza was just the best!
So much love poured into these custom cookies. Happy 5th Birthday! 💖
#MermaidCookies #5thBirthday #CustomCookies #CookieArt #BirthdayCookies #MermaidParty #SmallBusinessLove #FriendsWhoBake #MaplewoodMoms
Flashback to exactly one month ago: I was deep in the creative zone making a Father's Day cookie set for my dad! 🏒
One of my frequent taste-testers from day one, he totally deserved a custom set of cookies. The coolest part? We took photos of him and my brother's ice hockey team, transformed them into comic book art, and printed them right onto these royal icing sugar cookies! How fun is that?!
#FathersDay #CookieMagic #CustomMade #IceHockey #ComicBookArt #EdiblePrints #RoyalIcingCookies #MakingMagicEasy #CoolCookies #FamilyFun
Talk about a sweet collaboration! 🎨🍪 I had the absolute pleasure of creating these unique sugar cookies for a "meet the artist" event for the incredible @cigarettesandkale.
Who knew art could be this delicious? We took her amazing works and printed them onto the sweetest canvas: custom sugar cookies! It was so much fun seeing her art come to life in a whole new, edible way.
If you're ever looking to make a statement at your next local event, know that your vision can always be brought to life – perhaps even on a cookie! 😉
#MeetTheArtist #CigarettesAndKale #CustomCookies #EdibleArt #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #LocalBusiness #SupportLocal #SweetTreats
It's Theme Thursday, Maplewood and S.O., and today we're sprinkling some serious fairy dust with a Disney Princess Party fit for royalty! 👑✨
Forget basic balloons – we're talking full-on magical decor, a wardrobe full of princess dress-up gowns (because every little royal needs options!), and the most enchanting sparkly castle favor boxes you ever did see. But the crown jewel? A life-size cardboard castle ready for all your little guests to decorate themselves!
Imagine the giggles, the glitter, and the pure joy. Who needs a fairy godmother when you have a party like this? 😉
What's your favorite princess party detail? Let me know below! 👇 #ThemeThursday #DisneyPrincessParty #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #CustomCookies #LocalMoms #PartyIdeas
"Here Comes the Son" ☀️ and these sweet mini cookies were ready to shine at a recent baby shower! Seriously, how cute are these little suns, all tied up with a bright yellow bow?
Such a delightful way to celebrate a little ray of sunshine on the way! Congrats to the happy family!
Got a shower coming up? Let's brainstorm some adorable cookie ideas to welcome your little one! DM me to start planning.
#HereComesTheSon #BabyShowerCookies #SunCookies #MiniCookies #CustomCookies #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #BabyShowerIdeas #ItsABoy #CookieFavors #SweetTreats
Remember that guessing game we played the other day? The one where I asked you to predict the number of cookie cutters I have in my collection? Well, the results are in, and the total is even higher than I was expecting (but lower than my 7-year-old predicted, she swore I had “infinity” because I just “keep making them!”).
So why the obsession? Well, when you order custom cookies from me, you’re not just getting a treat; you’re getting a tiny work of art, often with a custom-designed and 3D-printed cutter just for you! It’s all about bringing your unique vision to life, whether it’s for birthdays, showers, sports, or even local business events. The sweet outcome for you is perfect, personalized cookies; the outcome for me is… more cookie cutters!
Are you ready for the big reveal?
Get ready to see if you’re a cookie-cutter-counting champ!
My grand total is… 🥁 330!
Did you nail it or were you way off? Let me know in the comments! 👇
👋 Hey there, cookie crew! It's Victoria, the face behind Making Magic Easy. You might know me for turning your party dreams into delicious cookie realities, but have you ever wondered how this whole sweet adventure started? 🤩
Well, rewind to August 2021. My youngest was turning two, and after a long stretch of no big parties (thanks, COVID), my "Two Sweet" birthday vision was HUGE. Being the relentless DIYer I am, I looked at those perfectly decorated sugar cookies I wanted and thought, "I can totally do that myself!" 🤣 (That's my then 2-year-old, in my mom's lap, who couldn't wait to dig into her cookies in the photo!).
And just like that, a new obsession was born (swipe to see a pic of the OG cookies)! What started as a labor of love for my daughter's bash quickly grew, and I officially started offering custom cookies to our amazing community in November 2023.
It's been a wild, wonderful ride, fueled by a lot of learning and a little bit of magic (and maybe some late-night Bravo). ✨
Tell me, what's something you DIY'd that totally surprised you with how much you loved it? 👇
#MeetTheBaker #MakingMagicEasy #CookieJourney #DIYSpirit #SmallBusinessStory #FirstCookies #MaplewoodMoms #HomeBaker #SupportLocal
Ready to make the whole place shimmer?! ✨🧜♀️
My latest mermaid set is giving major “Bejeweled” vibes with that airbrushed sheen. Perfect for your next sparkly celebration!
#CustomCookies #MermaidParty #Bejeweled #LocalNJ #SweetTreats #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #SupportLocal
Mermaid magic for a sweet 5th birthday! 🧜♀️✨
It's always extra special when I get to create for a friend, and being a tiny part of this perfectly curated mermaid extravaganza was just the best!
So much love poured into these custom cookies. Happy 5th Birthday! 💖
#MermaidCookies #5thBirthday #CustomCookies #CookieArt #BirthdayCookies #MermaidParty #SmallBusinessLove #FriendsWhoBake #MaplewoodMoms
Flashback to exactly one month ago: I was deep in the creative zone making a Father's Day cookie set for my dad! 🏒
One of my frequent taste-testers from day one, he totally deserved a custom set of cookies. The coolest part? We took photos of him and my brother's ice hockey team, transformed them into comic book art, and printed them right onto these royal icing sugar cookies! How fun is that?!
#FathersDay #CookieMagic #CustomMade #IceHockey #ComicBookArt #EdiblePrints #RoyalIcingCookies #MakingMagicEasy #CoolCookies #FamilyFun
Talk about a sweet collaboration! 🎨🍪 I had the absolute pleasure of creating these unique sugar cookies for a "meet the artist" event for the incredible @cigarettesandkale.
Who knew art could be this delicious? We took her amazing works and printed them onto the sweetest canvas: custom sugar cookies! It was so much fun seeing her art come to life in a whole new, edible way.
If you're ever looking to make a statement at your next local event, know that your vision can always be brought to life – perhaps even on a cookie! 😉
#MeetTheArtist #CigarettesAndKale #CustomCookies #EdibleArt #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #LocalBusiness #SupportLocal #SweetTreats
It's Theme Thursday, Maplewood and S.O., and today we're sprinkling some serious fairy dust with a Disney Princess Party fit for royalty! 👑✨
Forget basic balloons – we're talking full-on magical decor, a wardrobe full of princess dress-up gowns (because every little royal needs options!), and the most enchanting sparkly castle favor boxes you ever did see. But the crown jewel? A life-size cardboard castle ready for all your little guests to decorate themselves!
Imagine the giggles, the glitter, and the pure joy. Who needs a fairy godmother when you have a party like this? 😉
What's your favorite princess party detail? Let me know below! 👇 #ThemeThursday #DisneyPrincessParty #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #CustomCookies #LocalMoms #PartyIdeas
"Here Comes the Son" ☀️ and these sweet mini cookies were ready to shine at a recent baby shower! Seriously, how cute are these little suns, all tied up with a bright yellow bow?
Such a delightful way to celebrate a little ray of sunshine on the way! Congrats to the happy family!
Got a shower coming up? Let's brainstorm some adorable cookie ideas to welcome your little one! DM me to start planning.
#HereComesTheSon #BabyShowerCookies #SunCookies #MiniCookies #CustomCookies #MaplewoodNJ #SouthOrangeNJ #EssexCountyMoms #BabyShowerIdeas #ItsABoy #CookieFavors #SweetTreats
Remember that guessing game we played the other day? The one where I asked you to predict the number of cookie cutters I have in my collection? Well, the results are in, and the total is even higher than I was expecting (but lower than my 7-year-old predicted, she swore I had “infinity” because I just “keep making them!”).
So why the obsession? Well, when you order custom cookies from me, you’re not just getting a treat; you’re getting a tiny work of art, often with a custom-designed and 3D-printed cutter just for you! It’s all about bringing your unique vision to life, whether it’s for birthdays, showers, sports, or even local business events. The sweet outcome for you is perfect, personalized cookies; the outcome for me is… more cookie cutters!
Are you ready for the big reveal?
Get ready to see if you’re a cookie-cutter-counting champ!
My grand total is… 🥁 330!
Did you nail it or were you way off? Let me know in the comments! 👇