Baking magical moments, one batch at a time
Custom sugar cookies
Order NowHand crafted, just for you
Each cookie set is custom designed and made from scratch. From custom 3d printed cookie cutters to hand painted details, I give special attention to each cookie design.
Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or looking for a unique gift, Your custom sugar cookies are sure to create some magic.
COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES IN NJ
SUGAR COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES!
Perfect for a fun night out with friends or a unique team building activity, and learn something while you’re at it! You’ll walk away from our classes with 3-6 beautifully decorated cookies — done completely by you. Recipes, icing consistency, practice forms, pre-made cookies — everything you need is included along with live instruction.
Learn More
REVIEWS
Behind The Scenes
@COOKIEMAGIC_NJ
Marking 90 years with beautiful blue hydrangeas!
💍These cookies are extra special because they were made to celebrate the wedding of one of my oldest friend’s son!
Wishing the couple a lifetime of happiness (and cookies)!!
🍎📝 It's the time you've been waiting for (and I know that because of just how many messages I've received asking about Back to School cookies)!!
Orders are open from now through Sunday, August 22.
Free SOMA delivery on Monday, August 31, or you can pickup at my Maplewood location between 3-9pm on August 31.
⏰Limited quantities available. Don't miss out on my most highly anticipated sale of the year!
🍌This 10-year old and her friends are obsessed with squishies and NeeDohs…
so we turned some of her favorites into cookies for her party!
😀🌸 It's a smiley face/flower power theme for this 6-year-old's birthday party!
We even tied in the bubble-themed venue with the background print on the peace sign… I love adding in little details like these 🫧
🍼🐉 How cute is this baby dragon baby shower theme?
Hatching soon!!
I spoke too soon!
🎓 *now* I'm finished with grad cookies for the year
Congrats to all the 2026 grads!
🎬🍿 This mom reached out requesting cookies for a movie theater themed 6th birthday, saying her daughter loves "pink/blue/black/silver/sparkles"…
And I delievered!
It never gets old hearing that this 6-year-old's first request for his birthday parties is my cookies!
And it's particularly sweet designing brother-sister sets incorporating both of their ages 👫
Now I wonder what theme I'll be doing this time next year 🤔
💍These cookies are extra special because they were made to celebrate the wedding of one of my oldest friend’s son!
Wishing the couple a lifetime of happiness (and cookies)!!
🍎📝 It's the time you've been waiting for (and I know that because of just how many messages I've received asking about Back to School cookies)!!
Orders are open from now through Sunday, August 22.
Free SOMA delivery on Monday, August 31, or you can pickup at my Maplewood location between 3-9pm on August 31.
⏰Limited quantities available. Don't miss out on my most highly anticipated sale of the year!
🍌This 10-year old and her friends are obsessed with squishies and NeeDohs…
so we turned some of her favorites into cookies for her party!
😀🌸 It's a smiley face/flower power theme for this 6-year-old's birthday party!
We even tied in the bubble-themed venue with the background print on the peace sign… I love adding in little details like these 🫧
🍼🐉 How cute is this baby dragon baby shower theme?
Hatching soon!!
I spoke too soon!
🎓 *now* I'm finished with grad cookies for the year
Congrats to all the 2026 grads!
🎬🍿 This mom reached out requesting cookies for a movie theater themed 6th birthday, saying her daughter loves "pink/blue/black/silver/sparkles"…
And I delievered!
It never gets old hearing that this 6-year-old's first request for his birthday parties is my cookies!
And it's particularly sweet designing brother-sister sets incorporating both of their ages 👫
Now I wonder what theme I'll be doing this time next year 🤔