Baking magical moments, one batch at a time
Custom sugar cookies
Order NowHand crafted, just for you
Each cookie set is custom designed and made from scratch. From custom 3d printed cookie cutters to hand painted details, I give special attention to each cookie design.
Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or looking for a unique gift, Your custom sugar cookies are sure to create some magic.
COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES IN NJ
SUGAR COOKIE DECORATING CLASSES!
Perfect for a fun night out with friends or a unique team building activity, and learn something while you’re at it! You’ll walk away from our classes with 3-6 beautifully decorated cookies — done completely by you. Recipes, icing consistency, practice forms, pre-made cookies — everything you need is included along with live instruction.
Learn More
REVIEWS
Behind The Scenes
@COOKIEMAGIC_NJ
🀄🐉 I jumped the gun sharing my latest mahjong cookie set two weeks ago because today is National Mahjong Day!
So I'm taking the opportunity to share the different tiles I've brought to life in sugar!
❤️🍎✏️ Teacher Appreciation week is May 4-8 (next week)!
Gift those teachers in your life something sweet!
This year I'm offering:
🍎 Mini Apple Cookie Jar (4 mini cookies)
🍎 Single Sugar Cookie Box (personalize with your teacher's name!)
🍎 Double Sugar Cookie Box
🍎 Gourmet Stuffed Cookie Box (⚡ new this year!)
Order now for SOMA delivery this Saturday or Maplewood pickup this Sunday.
🔗 Link in Bio
🙋 And while you're at it, pick up a little something sweet for yourself and your family!
I'm currently running a flash sale with Sugar Cookies and Gourmet Stuffed cookies at 3 for $12.
🖌 AND my kids have been begging me for Paint Your Own cookies, so I made a small batch and have a few of those on my site for purchase as well!
⚡️🦸♂️💪 Celebrating National Superhero Day with this Avengers themed birthday cookie set!
🍒👜 Celebrating the grand opening of the @coach store at @americandream with some sweet treats!
🦔💨💙 The second theme for this epic brother-sister birthday party was Sonic!
Check out my last post to see what this set was paired with on celebration day…
🩷🫧💚🧹 Today's a double header! Sharing the first cookie set I created for this brother-sister birthday party.
She chose Wicked as her theme, what do you think the second theme will be??
🀄 I may not have any idea how to play mahjong, but I've sure had a lot of practice turning the tiles into cookies!
🦄 Who knew that today was National Unicorn Day?
And fun fact, all but one of the MANY unicorn themed cookies I've designed have been for fourth birthdays (like a few of my favorites here)!
🧵 Sewing birthday party… check
😍 Emoji pillow activity… check
I think we nailed this theme, even down to the (birthday girls') request to add the stitches around the edge of the emoji cookie so it would look just like the pillows they were making!
❤️🍎✏️ Teacher Appreciation week is May 4-8 (next week)!
Gift those teachers in your life something sweet!
This year I'm offering:
🍎 Mini Apple Cookie Jar (4 mini cookies)
🍎 Single Sugar Cookie Box (personalize with your teacher's name!)
🍎 Double Sugar Cookie Box
🍎 Gourmet Stuffed Cookie Box (⚡ new this year!)
Order now for SOMA delivery this Saturday or Maplewood pickup this Sunday.
🔗 Link in Bio
🙋 And while you're at it, pick up a little something sweet for yourself and your family!
I'm currently running a flash sale with Sugar Cookies and Gourmet Stuffed cookies at 3 for $12.
🖌 AND my kids have been begging me for Paint Your Own cookies, so I made a small batch and have a few of those on my site for purchase as well!
⚡️🦸♂️💪 Celebrating National Superhero Day with this Avengers themed birthday cookie set!
🍒👜 Celebrating the grand opening of the @coach store at @americandream with some sweet treats!
🦔💨💙 The second theme for this epic brother-sister birthday party was Sonic!
Check out my last post to see what this set was paired with on celebration day…
🩷🫧💚🧹 Today's a double header! Sharing the first cookie set I created for this brother-sister birthday party.
She chose Wicked as her theme, what do you think the second theme will be??
🀄 I may not have any idea how to play mahjong, but I've sure had a lot of practice turning the tiles into cookies!
🦄 Who knew that today was National Unicorn Day?
And fun fact, all but one of the MANY unicorn themed cookies I've designed have been for fourth birthdays (like a few of my favorites here)!
🧵 Sewing birthday party… check
😍 Emoji pillow activity… check
I think we nailed this theme, even down to the (birthday girls') request to add the stitches around the edge of the emoji cookie so it would look just like the pillows they were making!